After Hours: Analyzing the Impact of On-Call Duties On Social Workers’ Work-life Balance, Physical and Mental Health, and Service Delivery in Child Welfare

A Mixed-Methods Study

Cecilia Reyes, MSW

About Me

  • Fresno State Graduate
  • Title IV-E
    • Bachelors 2010
    • Masters 2025
  • Tulare County Child Welfare Services Social Worker since 2010

Cecilia Reyes in graduation regalia beside the Fresno State bulldog statue.

Why Examine On-Call Duties?

  • On-call coverage is legally and ethically required
  • Child Welfare Services operate 24/7
  • Limited research focuses specifically on on-call services in Child Welfare
  • Understanding impact is critical to workforce sustainability

Purpose of the Study

  • Examine the impact of on-call duties on social workers
  • Assess work-life balance outcomes
  • Explore physical and mental health impacts
  • Understand service delivery implications and coping

Gaps in the Literature

  • Limited Child Welfare specific research on on-call duties
  • Few studies center on the workers’ voice and lived experience
  • Minimal integration of service delivery outcomes
  • Limited focus on organizational policy implications

Literature Review

  • On-Call and extended work hours disrupt work-life balance
  • Long and unpredictable hours increase stress and burnout
  • Sleep disruption and fatigue are common among on-call workers
  • Non-standard hours strain family relationships and recovery time
  • Sleep disruption linked to fatigue and physical health concerns
  • Long work hours associated with cardiovascular and inflammatory risks
  • Fatigue impairs cognitive functioning and decision-making
  • Service quality may be affected under conditions of exhaustion

(A QR code with full references is provided at the end of the presentation.)

Research Design

  • Mixed-method study
  • Survey responses (n = 44)
  • In-depth semi-structured interviews (n = 9)
  • Focus on work-life balance, health, service delivery, and coping
  • Data triangulation to strengthen validity

Participant Characteristics

  • All survey participants were from Tulare County
  • Child Welfare Social Workers with on-call experience
  • Range of experience: 1 year to 10+ years
  • Majority caregivers and parents
  • Multiple program areas represented

Work-Life Balance Findings

  • 52.2% dissatisfied or very dissatisfied with work-life balance
  • 61.3% usually or always felt overwhelmed
  • 79.5% sometimes to always missed personal commitments
  • Feeling overwhelmed significantly predicted lower satisfaction (p = .004)

Physical Health Findings

  • 65.9% reported sleep was always disrupted while on-call
  • 52.3% usually or always felt physically fatigued
  • Exhaustion reported during and after on-call shifts
  • Limited recovery time between shifts

Mental Health Findings

  • High levels of stress and emotional fatigue are reported
  • 56.8% usually or always felt anxious or stressed
  • 59.1% usually or always felt overwhelmed by on-call duties
  • 50% rated their mental health as “fair.”
  • Anticipatory anxiety reported prior to on-call shifts (interviews)
  • Indicators consistent with burnout emerged across experience levels

Service Delivery Implications

  • Fatigue impacted concentration and decision-making
  • Reduced confidence in service quality reported
  • Feeling overwhelmed predicted reduced service confidence (p = .005)
  • Participants described ethical concerns related to fatigue and safety
  • High-stakes decisions occurred during periods of exhaustion and limited recovery

Coping Strategies Used by Workers

  • Peer and family support were most commonly used
  • Exercise, routines, and self-care practices assisted with stress management
  • Experience improved coping efficiency over time
  • Coping strategies were helpful, but were insufficient without recovery and organizational support

Interpreting Findings Through a Systems Lens

  • On-call stress is structurally produced
  • Staffing, scheduling, and recovery time are key drivers
  • Individual resilience has limits
  • Organizational conditions shape experience

Organizational Considerations

  • Voluntary on-call scheduling
  • Flexible scheduling options
  • Formal recovery time following on-call shifts
  • Role-specific on-call training
  • Consistent supervisory and peer support
  • Supports do not eliminate on-call; they support sustainability over time

Key Takeaways tied to Participant Responses

  • On-call duties significantly strain workers’ well-being
  • Chronic strain may affect retention and service quality over time
  • System-level supports contribute to sustainability

Closing Reflections and Future Directions

  • On-call is essential to timely response and child safety
  • A sustainable on-call structure benefits children & families, workers, and county agencies
  • Understanding these dynamics supports informed planning, continuity, and decision-making
  • Sustainability is not about eliminating on-call, but about maintaining capacity over time
  • Literature on child welfare-specific on-call models is limited; additional study is needed
  • Comparative research across counties and states could inform workforce and service delivery approaches
  • Exploring alternative models can help identify practices that benefit both county operations and the workforce
  • Thank you for your time and leadership

Sources

QR code labeled SCAN ME for presentation sources.

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.