Socioeconomic Status, Neighborhood and Home, Peer and Family Influence, and Social Capital as Predictors of Educational Success

Campus bridge and water beneath the presentation title and author information.

Denae J. Davis, MSW

Thesis submitted as a requirement of the CSU Stanislaus Master of Social Work program.

ABOUT ME

Portrait of Denae J. Davis alongside her personal background.

  • I have lived 97% of my life in San Joaquin and Stanislaus Counties.
  • I have worked full-time for Stanislaus County in various departments and capacities for 14 years.
  • I am from a large, low-socioeconomic status, single-parent family.
  • I am a first-generation student.

BACKGROUND: PERSONAL MOTIVATION FOR THE STUDY

  • Grew up in low-socioeconomic, single parent home.
  • Grew up in less-than-desirable neighborhoods with high crime, no sidewalks or safe pedestrian walkways, limited neighborhood resources, and experienced frequent moves.
  • Experienced wavering academic support or encouragement within the home and frequently felt “different” due to having academic goals.
  • Had limited access to social capital building activities.

BACKGROUND: COMMUNITY MOTIVATION FOR THE STUDY

Campus walkway and building shown beside information about Turlock schools and residents.

  • A majority of Turlock Unified School District (TUSD) schools receive funding through Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) to bridge educational gaps.
  • TUSD has an average high school graduation rate of 90%1.
  • With a four-year public university in the center of town, only 23.7% of Turlock’s residents aged 25 and older hold a bachelor’s degree or higher.

1Turlock Unified School District, 2018
2U.S. Census, 2010

STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM

Research Question:

Which combination of educational opportunities (socioeconomic status, neighborhood and home, peer and family influence, or social capital) best predict educational success?

Hypothesis

The underlying hypothesis is federal funding through ESSA is not enough to bridge educational gaps, nor is the funding enough to compensate for the impact the four educational opportunities have on educational success.

Definition of Variables:

  • Socioeconomic Status – Social class or standing often measured by income or education1.
  • Neighborhood and Home - Characterized by median income, social isolation, residential segregation, housing quality and stability, crime, drug use, quality and quantity of institutions such as schools, availability of childcare or social welfare resources, community organizations, recreational facilities, job market2.
  • Peer and Family Influence – An individual’s sense of belonging, peer group, support network3 and parental involvement or presence4.
  • Social Capital - “An aggregate concept that encompasses the association networks, norms, and trust that facilitate collective interactions for mutual economic and social benefits.”5

1American Psychological Association, 2021
2Gephart, 2017
3Crosnoe and Muller, 2014; Fowler, Metzger, & Swanstrom, 2018
4Hill & Taylor, 2004
5Groot, Huang, & van den Brink, 2011, p. 1012

LITERATURE REVIEW

Denier-Garageso-Bava Hall building beside the literature review material.

Socioeconomic Status: “Socioeconomic status often reveals inequities in access to resources, plus issues related to privilege, power and control”1.

Neighborhood and Home: Continuous childhood exposure to characteristics of high-poverty neighborhoods, including welfare receipt, single-parent homes, and poorly educated adults hinders chances of high school graduation2.

Peer and Family Influence: Peer groups are vital to school attachment3, “peers' choices and aspirations were positively related to a student's aspirations and choices”4, and parental educational involvement is strongly associated to student academic success5.

Social Capital: Extra-curricular or recreational activities provide youth opportunities to gain social capital, access to tangible resources, knowledge, and opportunities6.

1American Psychological Association, 2021, p. 1
2Elwert, Harding, and Wodtke, 2011, p. 713-714
3Fowler, Metzger, & Swanstrom 2018
4Rosenqvist, 2018, p. 73
5Benner, Boyle, & Sadler, 2016
6Hardaway & McLoyd, 2009, p. 250

METHODOLOGY

Research Design:

  • Quantitative study
  • Survey tool created using a combination of concepts from the Social Capital Measurement Tool, data from the American Community Survey, U.S. Census, and Community Equity Initiative.

Criteria to Participate in the Study:

  • Must be a student currently enrolled at CSU Stanislaus.

Data Collection:

  • Qualtrics - electronic circulation of the survey, via student email.
  • Survey tool sent via email a total of three times to 11,326 students.

Data Analysis:

  • Statistical Package for Social Sciences program
  • Used multiple regression, univariate, and bivariate analyses.

RESULTS

Campus building and landscape beside the sample size and demographics results.

Sample Size and Demographics:

  • 1,076 respondents, which is a 10.5% response rate.
  • Of that number, 113 respondents had matriculated through Turlock schools.
  • 74.2% (n = 821) respondents were undergraduate level (lower and upper divisions combined).
  • 24.6% (n = 264) respondents were post-baccalaureate (Master's, Doctor's, Credential).
  • 1.2% (n = 13) were in Open University Extended Education or did not indicate a program.

Socioeconomic Status

  • Nearly half (45.4%, n = 485) of the respondents receive socioeconomic status-based grants (CalGrant, Pell Grant, etc.).
  • 44.7% of mothers achieved at least some college or less.
  • 34.2% of fathers achieved at least some college or less.
  • Just over 80% of respondents have already surpassed their parent's education level, which indicates upward mobility.

Neighborhood and Home

Clouds over a campus landscape beside neighborhood safety and childhood-move results.

  • Of the 1,076 respondents, a combined 56.6% (n = 609) generally felt safe in their neighborhoods growing up, while 28.8% (n = 216) did not.
  • 29.2% (n=33) of those who generally felt unsafe were the sub-sect of respondents who matriculated through Turlock schools (“Turlock students”).
  • Childhood moves (N = 1,076):
    • 73.9% (n = 795) selected 0-4; 10.8% (n = 86) were Turlock students.
    • 20.3% (n = 218) selected 5-9; 10.6% (n = 23) were Turlock students.
    • 5.8% (n = 62) selected 10+; and 6.5% (n = 4) were Turlock students.
Residential Barriers Experienced by Respondents (N = 870)
Residential Barrier n %
My family used public resources (CalFresh, Medi-Cal, Section 8, etc.) 432 13.7
I was made responsible to care for my siblings 418 13.3
My family immigrated to the United States 383 12.2
I had to learn English as my second language 371 11.7
I had to translate for my parent/guardian as they did not speak English 369 11.7
I witnessed crime or violence outside of the home 297 9.4
I witnessed crime or violence inside the home 238 7.6
My family has had utility services disconnected (electricity/water, etc.) 185 5.9
My family spoke of working as a task more important than education 132 4.2
I had to work to help support the family home 128 4.1
My siblings cared for me more than my parent/guardian 102 3.2
My family experienced one or more eviction 96 3.0

Peer and Family Influence

Peer and Family Influence
Item Strongly Disagree (%) Disagree (%) Neither Agree nor Disagree (%) Agree (%) Strongly Agree (%) Total
Communication in home / ability to talk to parent(s) or adult family members 17.8 14.4 14.1 29.3 24.4 100
Homework help from parent(s) or adult family members 21.2 17.3 9.9 28.4 23.2 100
Supportive teachers, coaches, educators, and school staff 4.3 9.6 14.6 40.6 30.9 100
Strong support network of peers and friends 5.7 14.2 16.7 34.8 28.6 100

Social Capital

Social Capital
Item Strongly Disagree (%) Disagree (%) Neither Agree nor Disagree (%) Agree (%) Strongly Agree (%) Total
Extra-Curricular Activities 13.4 9.6 7.2 25.7 44.1 100
Family Support 15.1 10.3 12.1 22.2 40.3 100
Top 10 Resources as Indicated by Respondents (N = 1,076)
Resource (n)
Running Water 1044
Electricity 1032
Heating / Air Conditioning 939
Access to Healthcare (doctors, hospitals, mental health, dentist, etc.) 934
Parent / Guardian transportation 930
Adequate School Supplies (uniforms, equipment for school activities, etc.) 874
Bed (not shared with anyone else) 835
Three meals a day (available from/provided at home) 814
Internet 778
Sidewalks / Paved Roads 752

K-12 Experience vs. General Perceptions

K-12 Experience vs. General Perceptions
Item Most Present (n) Most Important (n) Present (n) Important (n) Somewhat Present (n) Somewhat Important (n) Not Present (n) Not important (n) Least Present (n) Least Important (n)
Essential resources (food, money, shelter) 454 493 290 236 251 244 57 70 25 34
Other resources (transportation, computer, internet) 45 118 213 257 508 513 154 106 157 83
Family support 338 243 179 154 387 436 101 144 72 100
Peer / community groups (sports, arts, agriculture, etc.) 55 19 78 32 320 252 302 305 322 469
Supportive teachers, coaches 51 77 117 124 329 379 313 296 267 201
Safe and/or stable housing 139 132 199 273 357 328 149 155 233 189

Barriers as a CSU Stanislaus Student

Top 10 Barriers Experienced by Respondents (N = 372)
Barrier n %
COVID-19 Pandemic 93 19
Lack of Belonging 60 12
Cost of Attendance 46 10
Lack of Navigation (resources, general campus) 40 8
Personal Finances and Lack of Basic Needs 33 7
Lack of Academic / Student Support 28 7
Commuting and / or Transportation 26 5
Faculty 26 5
Limited Access to Resources or Personal Support 23 5
Lack of Diversity / Inclusion 22 5

Correlations between respondent current education level, supportive teachers/coaches, participation in and support of extra-curricular activities.

Correlations between respondent current education level, supportive teachers/coaches, participation in and support of extra-curricular activities.
Variable Measure Respondent Education Level Supportive Teachers/Coaches Participation in Extra-Curricular Activities Family Support in Extra Curricular Activities
Respondent Education Level Pearson Correlation 1 -.076* -.063* -.090**
Sig. (2-tailed)   .013 .039 .003
N 1076 1075 1075 1076

*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed)
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed)

SUMMARY

Campus building, exterior stairs, and landscaped flowers beside the study summary.

Findings of this study:

  • Do not support the hypothesis because students are upwardly mobile regardless of socioeconomic status, neighborhood and home, or peer and family influences.
  • Do show evidence of correlation between aspects of social capital and educational attainment.
  • Show that students who matriculated through the Turlock school system were on-par with their non-Turlock counterparts.

Limitations

  • 10% of responses were TUSD matriculated students, which was only 1% of total responses and not a large enough sample to explain the educational gap in Turlock.
  • There lacks a consistent tool to measure social capital.

Areas for Further Research

  • Theoretically produce a consistent tool for measuring social capital.
  • Conduct a longitudinal study among TUSD students of ESSA receiving schools throughout their educational experience.

Implications for Social Work

  • Engage clients in social capital building activities.
  • Train educators on Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) and how to support students/families who may have experienced adversity.
  • Emphasize the importance of parental involvement in children's education and functions.
  • Advocate and lobby for educational policies, school funding, and more flexibility in school choice.

“Social workers should act to expand choice and opportunity for all people, with special regard for vulnerable, disadvantaged, oppressed, and exploited people and groups.”1

1NASW Code of Ethics 6.04(b), 2017.

QUESTIONS...

View looking up between tall buildings beside the closing questions slide.

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.