A Qualitative Study Exploring the Effects of Multiple Placement Changes for Minors in Foster Care
Presented by: Efrain Barboza, MSW
Supported by: Kelly Woodard, MSW & Dr. Marcus Crawford
Presentation Outline
- Title of Research
- Presentation Outline
- Introduction
- Introduction Cont.
- Purpose
- Methods
- Methods Cont.
- Results
- Results Cont.
- Discussion & Recommendations
- Discussion & Recommendations Cont.
- Discussion & Recommendations Cont.
- Conclusion
- Contact information
- References
Introduction
- Child welfare systems face unique challenges.
- Children in out of home non-kinship care are 1.7 times more likely to be moved into congregate care than children placed in kinship care.1
- One in three children experience placement instability.2
1. Palmer et al., 2020. 2. Rubin et al., 2004. 3. Khoo & Skoog, 2014. 4. Creswell & Creswell, 2018.
Introduction Cont.
- Placement breakdowns can occur due to a variety of issues, often occurring after culmination of multiple events.3
- This qualitative study used a hermeneutical phenological research design.
- Goal of this research was to examine outcomes associated with placement changes from the perspective of the children living this experience.
1. Palmer et al., 2020. 2. Rubin et al., 2004. 3. Khoo & Skoog, 2014. 4. Creswell & Creswell, 2018.
Purpose
- Research information can be used to help prevent continued trauma for children while in foster care.
- The research explores “What is the lived experience of teenagers in foster care that have had multiple placement changes?”
- Research findings can help social workers make better informed decisions when placing or moving children that are in out-of-home care.
Methods
- Participants in this study were teenagers in foster care.
- Sample included four teenagers who were new to care and five teenagers who have been in care for at least a year.
- Participants in the study ranged from 12 to 17 years old.
- Participants were recruited through a foster family agency.
Methods Cont.
- Data was collected through virtual interviews which were recorded.
- Questions that were asked during the interview explored concepts associated with placement instability and aging while in foster care.
- Semi-structured interview guide was used for the interviews.
Results
| Name | Gender | Age | Ethnicity | Time in Foster Care | Time in Current Placement |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kelly | Female | 15 | Mexican | 1 Year | 1 Year |
| Lisa | Female | 12 | Mexican | 1 Year | 1 Year |
| Kyle | Female | 13 | Hmong | 1 Year | 6 Months |
| Gina | Female | 17 | Hmong | 1 Year | 4-5 Months |
| Whitney | Female | 14 | Asian | 1 Year | 6 Months |
| Erika | Female | 16 | Hmong | 1 Year | 4-5 Months |
| John | Male | 12 | Mexican/American | 3-4 Years | 3-4 Years |
| James | Male | 17 | White | 4 Years | 2 Years |
| Josh | Male | 14 | Hispanic | 4-5 Years | 2 Years |
Results Cont.
- Kelly (15) & Lisa (12) are siblings who were initially placed with a family member for six months and have lived with their current resource parents for the last six months.
- Kyle (13) & Whitney (14) are siblings who had been in out-of-home care for six months when they were younger and were reunified are currently back in care for another six months.
- Gina (17) & Erika (16) had previously been in out-of-home care for six months and were reunified, they have now been in their current placement for four months.
- John (12) has been in foster care for about four years and has only been in his current placement during that time.
- James (17) has been in out-of-home care for four years and has had four placement changes with his most current placement being the longest at two years.
- Josh (14) has been in out-of-home care between four and five years while having four placement changes with him being in his current placement for two years.
Discussion & Recommendations (1/3)
Improving Education
“To begin with it was like really bad like my grades were horrible but, when I got placed into the home I’m in right now, my grades improved like really good. My foster parents pushed me to do better.” (Josh, 2022)
- Practitioners should recognize that the children do care about their education.
- Practitioners who can makes decisions regarding a child’s placement should ask questions regarding the family’s educational standards.
- Despite it being well documented that moving a child into out-of-home care can be devastating.5
- Once the participants in the current study were provided stability through their current resource parents, they were able to see positive results in their grades.
1. Palmer et al., 2020. 2. Rubin et al., 2004. 3. Khoo & Skoog, 2014. 4. Creswell & Creswell, 2018. 5. Pardeck, 1985, as cited in Crum, 2010 & Newton et al., 2000.
Discussion & Recommendations (2/3)
Internalized Responsibilities
“Because, like, if I do something wrong, I’ll probably get replaced in this house. And if I don’t make good choices then I’ll get replaced in this house.” (Kelly, 15)
- Concerning theme that emerged was the sense of responsibility.
- The agencies and practitioners should do their best to promote the wellbeing.
- Navigating a conversation with the children allows them to take responsibility.
- One way to attempt to eliminate placement changes is to work on eliminating.
1. Palmer et al., 2020. 2. Rubin et al., 2004. 3. Khoo & Skoog, 2014. 4. Creswell & Creswell, 2018. 5. Pardeck, 1985, as cited in Crum, 2010 & Newton et al., 2000
Discussion & Recommendations (3/3)
Perceptions of Placements
“Where I’m at now. I feel like I can consider them my friends but like still like my parents.” (Josh, 2022)
- Youth who have had multiple placement changes had differing perceptions.
- Youth in the foster care system for a considerable amount had differing perceptions.
- Perceptions from those who have been in care multiple times.
- The findings demonstrated how detrimental placing out of county.
- All options should be considered before placing out of county.
1. Palmer et al., 2020. 2. Rubin et al., 2004. 3. Khoo & Skoog, 2014. 4. Creswell & Creswell, 2018. 5. Pardeck, 1985, as cited in Crum, 2010 & Newton et al., 2000.
Conclusion
- Research sought to explore multiple placement changes though the lens of youth currently in foster care.
- Research indicates that through new expectations and motivations, the participant’s grades improved while in out-of-home care. They report a sense of responsibility to maintain their placements promoting a need to be perfect.
- Research found that the youth that had been in care before and or in care longer had an easier time distinguishing between good homes and not so good homes.
- It is important to note that often the work that resource parents put into the children in their care goes unnoticed.
- John (12) stated it well: “[Resource parents are] choosing to take care of us. They want us to stay here because…, I don’t know. They just want us.”
Thank You
Central California Area Social Services Consortium
Efrain Barboza, MSW
(805) 598-7782
Ebarboza@fresnocountyca.gov
Support provided by:
Kelly Woodard, MSW
Dr. Marcus Crawford
References
Palmer, L., Ahn, E., Traube, D., Prindle, J., & Putnam-Hornstein, E. (2020). Correlates of entry into congregate care among a cohort of California foster youth. Children and Youth Services Review, 110. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2020.104772
Rubin, David M., Evaline A. Alessandrini, Chris Feudtner, David S. Mandell, A. Russell Localio, and Trevor Hadley. (2004). “Placement Stability and Mental Health Costs for Children in Foster Care.” Pediatrics 113 (5), 1336–41.
Khoo, E., & Skoog, V. (2014). The road to placement breakdown: Foster parents’ experiences of the events surrounding the unexpected ending of a child’s placement in their care. Qualitative Social Work, 13(2), 255–269. https://doi.org/10.1177/1473325012474017
Creswell, J. & Creswell, J.D. (2018). Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches, 5th Edition. Sage Publications.
Crum, Wes. “Foster Parent Parenting Characteristics That Lead to Increased Placement Stability or Disruption.” Children and Youth Services Review, vol. 32, no. 2, Elsevier Ltd, 2010, pp. 185–90, doi:10.1016/j.childyouth.2009.08.022.
Newton, R. R., Litrownik, A. J., & Landsverk, J. A. (2000). Children and youth in foster care: Disentangling the relationship between problem behaviors and number of placements. Child Abuse and Neglect, 24(10), 1363–1374. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0145-2134(00)00189-7
This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.