Fresno County Community Climate Change Survey

Fresno State Central Valley Health Policy Institute branding displayed on the research poster

Emanuel Alcala, PHD; Dustin Hedrick, B.A.; Armando Ramirez, B.A.; Josian Zuniga, B.S.

Fresno State Central Valley Health Policy Institute

20

Background

The effects of climate change have been shown to negatively impact San Joaquin Valley residents (Ganesh & Smith 2018). Agricultural labor productivity, migration, and housing are all pressing socio economic issues within the San Joaquin Valley that are also affected by climate change and are, inevitably, focal points within the local legislature. Thus, it is important to understand the overall knowledge, beliefs, and opinions on climate change in Fresno County to inform policymakers. To our knowledge, there has not been a survey study of this scale performed in the Central Valley. Our objectives are twofold:

  1. Identify relationships between the opinions and knowledge of Fresno County residents toward climate change according to their age, gender, race ethnicity, and place of residence.
  2. Highlight themes derived from statistical analysis to inform policymakers and community program directors.

Methods

Data was collected from a community-wide survey distributed in a cross-sectional study design. The survey utilized Likert-Type scales to quantitatively measure collected ordinal data. The survey was distributed to Fresno County residents using snowball and convenience sampling methods. SPSS software analyzed statistically significant trends among participant responses via one-way ANOVA test. Avenue for distribution of surveys included fliers, qr code and anonymous link.

Flyer distributed to Fresno County residents for their opinions and ideas on climate change

Bilingual Fresno County climate change survey flyer with English and Spanish survey instructions, QR codes, and an invitation to share opinions

PLEASE TAKE THIS SURVEY!

YOU CAN USE YOUR CAMERA OR QR APP TO READ THE QR CODE OR CLICK ON THE LINK BELOW.

Take the survey in English

We want to hear your thoughts on climate change

POR FAVOR TOME ESTA ENCUESTA!

PUEDE USAR SU CÁMARA O APLICACIÓN QR PARA LEER EL CÓDIGO QR O HACER CLIC EN EL ENLACE A CONTINUACIÓN.

Tome la encuesta en español

Queremos escuchar tu opinión sobre el cambio climático

Results

Demographic Characteristics

Figures 1 and 3 do not print individual bar values. Their frequencies below are approximate readings from the charts; the percentages and scores in the other figures are reproduced as printed.

Bar chart showing the frequency of survey participants by age group

Figure 1. Frequency of Age Groups (n=287)
Age group Approximate frequency
59+ Approximately 17
43-58 Approximately 13
26-42 Approximately 34
18-25 Approximately 197

Frequency axis: 0 to 250, in increments of 50.

Pie chart showing the percentage of survey participants by gender group

Figure 2. Percentage of Gender Groups (n=287)
Gender Percentage
Man 37%
Woman 63%

Bar chart showing the frequency of survey participants across race and ethnicity categories

Figure 3. Frequency of Race/Ethnicity (n=287)
Race/Ethnicity Approximate frequency
I don't know Approximately 2
I would prefer not to say Approximately 5
Multi-Racial Approximately 14
Other Race/Ethnicity Approximately 3
White Approximately 50
Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander Approximately 0
Asian Approximately 42
Latino, Hispanic or Spanish Approximately 151
Black or African American Approximately 10
American Indian or Alaska Native Approximately 4

Frequency axis: 0 to 160, in increments of 20.

Pie chart showing the percentages of survey participants by city district

Figure 4. Percentages of City Districts (n=170)
City district Percentage
1.00 23%
2.00 5%
3.00 7%
4.00 8%
5.00 8%
6.00 24%
7.00 25%

See Figure 15 for the scoring numbers used for the questions.

Age Groups

The source labels the second age group as 26-42 in Figure 1 and 26-43 in Figures 5-7.

Bar chart comparing age groups’ mean responses about knowing that environmental problems and issues are important

Figure 5. Mean of “Knowing about…” by Age Groups
Knowing about environmental problems and issues is important to me.
Age group Score
18-25 2.34
26-43 2.48
43-58 2.53
59+ 2.86

Bar chart comparing age groups’ support for a policy that regulates CO2 emissions as a pollutant

Figure 6. Would you support a regulatory CO2 Policy? by Age Groups
Would you support a policy that regulates CO2 (carbon dioxide) as a pollutant?
Age group Score
18-25 2.17
26-43 2.32
43-58 2.33
59+ 2.79

Bar chart comparing age groups’ responses about Fresno regulating land use better than in previous years

Figure 7. Fresno is doing a better job regulating land use by Age Groups
Fresno is doing a better job in regulating land use than in previous years.
Age group Score
18-25 1.49
26-43 1.19
43-58 1.00
59+ 0.67

Gender Groups

Bar chart comparing men’s and women’s responses about whether concerns over environmental problems have been exaggerated

Figure 8. Climate change is exaggerated by Gender Groups
I think most of the concerns about environmental problems have been exaggerated.
Gender Score
Man 1.05
Woman 0.62

Bar chart comparing men’s and women’s responses about whether global climate change will impact the environment in the next 10 years

Figure 9. Global climate change will impact our environment by Gender Groups
Global climate change will impact our environment in the next 10 years.
Gender Score
Man 2.6263
Woman 2.8136

Bar chart comparing men’s and women’s responses about whether local officials should do more to address climate change

Figure 10. Local officials need to do more by Gender Groups
Local officials should do more to address climate change.
Gender Score
Man 2.51
Woman 2.68

Race/Ethnicity Groups

Bar chart comparing race and ethnicity groups’ responses about whether it is a waste of time to try to solve environmental problems

Figure 11. It is a waste to try and solve by Race/Ethnicity groups
It is a waste of time to try and solve environmental problems.
Race/Ethnicity Score
White 0.22
Latino 0.31
Asian 0.10
African American/Black 0.32
Other 1.40

Bar chart comparing race and ethnicity groups’ responses about requiring lessons in schools to teach students about climate change

Figure 12. Should there be required lessons in schools by Race/Ethnicity groups
Should there be required lessons taught in schools to teach students about climate change?
Race/Ethnicity Score
White 2.72
Latino 2.50
Asian 2.74
African American/Black 2.82
Other 2.20

Bar chart comparing race and ethnicity groups’ responses about expanding offshore oil and gas drilling off the U.S. coast

Figure 13. We should expand offshore drilling by Race/Ethnicity Groups
We should expand offshore drilling for oil and gas off the US coast.
Race/Ethnicity Score
White 2.29
Latino 1.48
Asian 2.05
African American/Black 1.95
Other 2.25

Chart scale: 0.00 to 3.00, in increments of 0.50.

City District Groups

Bar chart showing city district groups’ responses to whether they can do much to help solve environmental problems

Figure 14. There is not much I can do to help by City District Groups.
There is not much I can do that will help solve environmental problems.
City district Score
7.00 0.79
6.00 1.12
5.00 1.31
4.00 0.64
3.00 0.77
2.00 0.63
1.00 1.31

Scoring numbers for questions

Figure 15. Scoring numbers for questions
Score Response
3 Strongly Agree
2 Somewhat Agree
1 Somewhat Disagree
0 Strongly Disagree

Discussion

Age

The age group 59+ was more willing to learn about environmental problems and issues, support more progressive environmental policies. They also show the lowest levels of confidence that Fresno is doing better regulating land use than in prior years. It is assumed the 59+ group have a better gauge of how Fresno has handled land use in the past and are more passionate compared to other groups who have less experience with environmental issues. The data shows that environmental issues are important to all age groups in Fresno County despite data from pew research that shows that younger generations are more willing to engage in environmental policy.

Gender

The differences between gender did not have high levels of variance. Men and women strongly disagreed that concerns were exaggerated about environmental problems. Both groups somewhat agree that global climate change will impact the environment in the next 10 years and want to see local officials do more about climate change. In research by Yale University men and women both expressed that climate change is happening but women expressed higher levels of risk perception than men

Race/Ethnicity

All groups strongly disagreed that it would be a waste of time to solve environmental problems. The groups would like to see more lessons of climate change being taught in schools. They showed varying levels of disagreement to expanding offshore drilling with Latinos and African Americans showing the highest levels of disagreements

City District

Each district expressed disagreement that they could not do anything about solving environmental problems.

Limitations

We used a convenience sample so these findings cannot be generalized to the entire population. We think some participants may not understand some of the questions (offshore drilling). Future surveys should include more questions about other demographics characteristics (i.e income, education level, occupation) to measure differences in those groups.

Conclusion

The survey is still receiving submissions from within the Fresno County area. Data will be analyzed again at a later date. It is important to continue data collection to hear from as many residents. Their voices will be instrumental for local officials creating climate change legislation that will protect the people of Fresno County.

Acknowledgements

Thank you to the Kresge foundation for helping to fund the project. The contents are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the official views of nor an endorsement, by the Kresge foundation. We would like to extend appreciation to our 5 partner organizations for helping to distribute the survey though their networks; Building Healthy Communities, Central California Environmental Justice Network, Central Valley Air Quality Coalition, Faith in the Valley, and Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability. We also thank Dr. Beth Weinman for help to distribute the survey. Without their support this poster would not have been possible.

THE KRESGE FOUNDATION

RESEARCH POSTER PRESENTATION DESIGN © 2011
www.PosterPresentations.com

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.