Importance of CHW Input Incorporation in Evaluation Methods

Presenter: Davenna Morales, BSc
Central Valley Health Policy Institute
California State University, Fresno

Abstract ID: 534777

INTRODUCTION

Davenna Morales, BSc

Pronouns: She/Her/Hers
Research Assistant
Central Valley Health Policy Institute (CVHPI)
California State University, Fresno

Portrait of Davenna Morales outdoors.

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURES

The Advancing Health Literacy - Fresno County team would like to extend a special thanks to these funders for making this project possible:

  • Fresno County
  • Office of Minority Health (OMH) of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)

There are no relationships to disclose or conflicts of interest for the activities presented in this presentation.

BACKGROUND: Advancing Health Literacy (AHL) Project

A CHW-led intervention targeted at improving structural and healthcare barriers within rural West Fresno

Mission of AHL:

  • increase in health literacy among residents to:
    • help address vaccine hesitancy
    • stop the spread of COVID-19
  • Work to eliminate health disparities within Fresno by increasing awareness on COVID-19 transmission, testing, and vaccines

BACKGROUND: Targeted Areas

  • Top agricultural-producing county in the United States
  • The highest concentrated poverty rate in California 1
  • Some of the targeted zip codes in this project (93210, 93640, 93657, 93606) have barriers that exceed the 90th percentile when compared to the rest of the nation for the following burdens 2:
    • Housing Burden
    • DOT Transportation Barriers
    • Linguistic Isolation

Source:

  1. Fresno Economic Opportunities Commissions. (2022, November 13). Strategic Planning- Poverty in Fresno County. Fresno EOC. https://fresnoeoc.org/strategic-planning-poverty-in-fresno-county/
  2. Climate and Ecconomic Justice Screening Tool, Data 2023, https://screeningtool.geoplatform.gov/en/#16.67/36.729446/-119.708855

BACKGROUND: AHL Project

Role of CHW’s:

  1. Conduct outreach to connect with participants who experience one or more barriers to health literacy (SDOH)
  2. Administer Baseline Needs Assessment, give health education materials, and provide referral
  3. Deliver Follow Up assessments to see referral success

Community health workers at an outreach table with health information and resources.

Group of community health workers and project participants standing together.

Community health workers sharing health resources at an outreach table.

What We Saw: Low Referral Rates

The charts show referrals requested and contacts made or referrals initiated for each category.

Positive Screening: Referrals Requested vs Contact Made/Initiated

Bar chart comparing referrals requested on assessment with referral contacts made or initiated by social determinants of health: Food Insecurity 49 requested and 8 contacted; Housing Instability 25 and 3; Financial Instability 41 and 0; Personal Safety Concern 10 and 0; Lack of Transportation 32 and 6.

Positive Screening: Referrals Requested vs Contact Made/Initiated
SDOH Referrals Requested On Assessment Referral Contact Made/Initiated
Food Insecurity 49 8
Housing Instability 25 3
Financial Instability 41 0
Personal Safety Concern 10 0
Lack of Transportation 32 6

Referral Type: Referrals Requested vs Initiated

Bar chart comparing referrals requested on assessment with referrals initiated by type: Primary Care 36 requested and 4 initiated; Dental Care 33 and 5; Mental Health 28 and 6; Substance Use 5 and 0; Immigration Legal Services 32 and 2.

Referral Type: Referrals Requested vs Initiated
Referral Type Referrals Requested on Assessment Referrals Initiated
Primary Care 36 4
Dental Care 33 5
Mental Health 28 6
Substance Use 5 0
Immigration Legal Services 32 2

METHODS: What We Did

  1. CHW Phone Interviews

    • Conducted 8, one-on-one anonymous phone interviews (30-60 min each) with project CHW’s
    • Questions centered the CHW’s:
      • field experience
      • identifying systemic and organizational barriers
  2. Data Analysis

    • CHW Interview content was analysed using grounded theory to establish themes
  3. Disseminate Findings & Next Steps

    • Findings were discussed with partners and CHWs
    • Yielded next steps and support building during grant period

CHW INTERVIEW FINDINGS

Lack of Essential Services

Lack of Essential Services
Service Barriers
Transportation
  • Clients are unable to access referrals because of limited transportation or do not have access to transportation at all
  • Financial constraints: clients can only afford enough gas to go home, work, or school
Housing
  • Clients needing housing do not have an address to send resources to
  • Few affordable housing options and long waitlists (months to years)
Medical & Dental services
  • Lack of transportation and no local medical offices prevented many from seeking care
  • Medi-cal and other insurance does not cover all expenses, so patients are unable to get care

Cascade of Unmet Needs

Lack of Access (Housing, Transportation, Medical Services) leads to:

  • Client Mistrust and Misunderstanding
  • Inability to overcome barriers with health education alone

Both lead to CHW Burnout and Emotional Burden.

Diagram showing a cascade of unmet needs: lack of access to housing, transportation, and medical services; client mistrust and misunderstanding; inability to overcome barriers with health education alone; and CHW burnout and emotional burden.

Word Cloud

  • “Nothing Ever Changes”
  • “I’m Already on the Waitlist”
  • Hit a Wall When Doing Referrals
  • Given Wrong Addresses, Wrong Phone Numbers
  • Long-lasting Change is Hard Due To Turnover
  • “I Only Have Enough Gas for School and Work”
  • It’s Difficult to Sustain Impact Due to Grant Changes
  • Clients Feel Hopeless
  • We Are Stretched Thin
  • We Use The Services We Do Have to Offset other needs
  • “I Don’t Need Housing Assistance, I Don’t Have a Home”
  • “I’m Too Busy to Seek Services”
  • “There’s Not Alot Out Here, It’s All Far Away”
  • Not Many Reliable Transportation Options
  • Services Don’t Always Meet Client Needs
  • Change Here Is Slow and Gradual
  • It’s Hard to Locate Clients Again
  • “I’m Not Crazy”
  • They Need Services Now But Can’t Get Them
  • We Can’t Support Them As Well As We Want

CHW Burden and Burnout

Organizational barriers/grantwork

  • Phrasing of assessment questions affected CHW ability to connect and build relationships with community members
  • Length of the Assessment also affected rapport building
  • Different levels of experience and training
  • Involvement in several projects was hard to juggle
  • Short grant periods

NEXT STEPS

  1. Info Dissemination and Discussions

    • Presented findings to partners
    • Discussed next steps with the AHL Project
  2. Incorporation of CHW Feedback

    • CHW trainings in requested areas
    • CVHPI administered surveys to CHW’s to gather continuous feedback as the project progressed

IMPORTANCE

Fresno specific:

  • Highlighted systemic challenges and barriers from perspective of West Fresno citizens and CHW’s

Across Grantwork:

  • CHW input highlighted the systemic and organizational barriers
  • The value CHW feedback brings to community based interventions

The diagram shows the connected relationship between CHW Burnout, Client Mistrust, and Lack of Services.

  • Lack of Services leads to Client Mistrust.
  • Lack of Services leads to CHW Burnout.
  • Client Mistrust leads to CHW Burnout.

Recommendations

  • Incorporating CHW input when writing health assessments, community intervention goals, etc
  • Recognizing CHW’s as an essential part of the healthcare team
    • Pushing for CHW reimbursement from insurance and other “hard money” means
  • Developing trainings that equip CHW’s with transferable skills in all grant work
  • Advocating for grant funding for CHW-led interventions
  • Continuing the discussion surrounding the value CHW work and perspectives bring to addressing disparity

Thank You!

AUTHORS:

Davenna Morales, BS; Kate Ingram, MPH; Dustin Hedrick, BA;
Emanuel Alcala, PhD

QUESTIONS PLEASE CONTACT:

Davenna Morales
davennam@mail.fresnostate.edu

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.