Geospatial Analysis of the Association between Food Deserts, Transportation, and Hypertension Prevalence in California

Grant Mendoza, MPH Candidate, Emanuel Alcala, PHD

Fresno State
Central Valley Health Policy Institute

16

Background

  • In the United States, about 120 million adults are diagnosed with hypertension.
  • In California, hypertension prevalence is 27.9%, and a mortality rate of 14.7%.
  • Individual-level risk factors
    • Diet, physical activity, and genetics.
  • Geospatial risk factors
    • Food deserts w/ transportation, walkability, park access, and urban/rural status at the census tract level.
  • Testa (2021) and Suarez (2015) both investigated food deserts and their association with hypertension, but they used individual-level data rather than other community-level measures.
  • Green and colleagues (2022) state that future research should focus on community-level socioeconomic status and hypertension prevalence to better understand the determinants of hypertension.
  • Koh and colleagues (2022) suggest further research on green spaces and health outcomes to better understand green spaces.

Problem Statement

  • There is a significant gap in research in understanding the association of geospatial factors with hypertension prevalence in California at the census tract level.
  • To my knowledge, there is no comprehensive study that investigates the combined effects of geospatial factors such as food deserts w/ transportation, walkability, park access, and urban/rural status on hypertension prevalence in California at the census tract level.

Research Question

  • Is there an association between hypertension prevalence and geospatial factors such as food deserts w/ transportation, walkability, park access, and urban/rural status in California at the census tract level?

Methods

Databases and Measures

  • CDC PLACES
    • Hypertension prevalence (DV)
  • USDA Food Access Research Atlas
    • Food desert w/ transportation and urban/rural status
  • Healthy Places Index 3.0
    • Access to healthcare, park access, race/ethnicity, poverty, education
  • American Community Survey
    • Age
  • National Walkability Index
    • Walkability score

Data Processing

  1. The data was cleaned to remove missing values, outliers, or errors affecting the analysis.
  2. The independent variables were standardized by Z-score.
  3. To avoid collinearity issues, a composite score named “cumulative socioeconomic advantage” was created with the following measures:
    • access to healthcare, education, and above-poverty.

Data Analysis

  • Univariate
    • Frequency distribution and descriptive statistics
  • Bivariate
    • Simple linear regression
  • Multivariate
    • Multiple linear regression

Results

Maps and Descriptive Results

Figure 1. Map of Hypertension Prevalence by Census Tracts, California, 2021

Map of California census tracts showing hypertension prevalence; darker blue indicates higher prevalence.
  • Figure 1, shows prevalence of hypertension. The darkest shade of blue represents 31% - 56%.
  • The medium shade of blue represents 25% - 31%.
  • The lowest values are 6% - 25% and represent the light shade of blue.

Figure 2. Map of Food Deserts Lacking Transportation by Census Tracts, California, 2019

Map of California census tracts distinguishing food deserts lacking transportation from non-food deserts.
  • Figure 2, shows food deserts lacking transportation. The darkest shade of blue represents food deserts lacking transportation.

Figure 3. Map of Cumulative Socioeconomic Advantage by Census Tracts, California, 2022

Map of California census tracts showing cumulative socioeconomic advantage; darker blue indicates higher advantage.
  • Figure 3, shows cumulative socioeconomic advantage. The darkest shade of blue represents 67% - 100% which indicates a higher advantage.
  • The lighter shade of blue represents 0% - 67%, or a disadvantaged tract.

Figure 4. Map of Percent Age 55+ by Census Tracts, California, 2019

Map of California census tracts showing the percentage of residents age 55 and older.
  • Figure 4, shows percent age 55+. The darkest shade of blue represents 40% - 100%.
  • The medium shade of blue represents 25% - 40%.
  • The lowest values are 0% - 25%, and are indicated by the light shade of blue.
Frequency Statistics of Categorical Variables
Variables N %
Non-Food Deserts 7519 93.7
Food Deserts lacking Transportation 505 6.3
Urban 7353 91.6
Rural 671 8.4

Source image of the frequency statistics table listing non-food deserts, food deserts lacking transportation, urban, and rural counts and percentages.

Descriptive Statistics of Continuous Variables
Variable N Min Max Mean SD
Geospatial factors
Hypertension prevalence 8005 5.60 56.40 26.98 4.79
Park Access 7790 0.00 1.00 0.77 0.31
Walkability 8057 1.00 19.67 12.14 3.54
Community-level factors
Cumulative Socioeconomic Advantage 7790 -1.70 1.35 0.07 0.14
Age 55+ 8012 0.00 1.00 0.27 0.11
Percent Black 8012 0.00 0.85 0.06 0.09

N = Number of census tracts

Source image of descriptive statistics for geospatial and community-level factors, including hypertension prevalence, park access, walkability, cumulative socioeconomic advantage, age 55+, and percent Black.

  • The walkability average of 12.14 equates to an average of 65% walkable per census tract.
  • The Cumulative Socioeconomic Advantage average of 0.07 equates to 42% advantage per census tract.

Figure 5. Map of Walkability by Census Tracts, California, 2021

Map of California census tracts showing low, moderate, and high walkability.
  • Figure 5, shows walkability. The darkest shade of blue represents census tracts of high walkability.
  • The medium shade of blue represents moderate walkability.
  • The light shade of blue represents low walkability.

Multiple Linear Regression

Multiple Linear Regression
Variables B Std. Error 95% CI P
(Constant) 27.23 .126 26.98, 27.48 0
Food Deserts lacking Transportation 1.96 .123 1.72, 2.20 <.001
Cumulative Socioeconomic Advantage -2.84 .040 -2.92, -2.76 <.001
Age 55+ 3.94 .036 3.87, 4.01 <.001
Percent Black 1.05 .031 .99, 1.10 <.001
Walkability -.37 .037 -.44, -.29 <.001
Park Access -.15 .032 -.21, -.08 <.001
Urban -.32 .132 -.58, -.06 0.015

The multiple linear regression was statistically significant (R2 = 0.684, p = <.001).

Source image of the multiple linear regression table, including coefficients, standard errors, confidence intervals, and p-values.

The Final Analysis shows:

  • Areas lacking access to healthy food options due to transportation issues have a positive association with hypertension prevalence (b = 1.96; 95% CI 1.72, 2.20).
  • Higher cumulative socioeconomic advantage is associated with lower hypertension prevalence (b = -2.84; 95% CI -2.92, -2.76).
  • Communities with higher percentages of individuals aged 55 and above were found to have an increased risk of hypertension (b = 3.94; 95% CI 3.87, 4.01).
  • All variables have statistically significant relationships with hypertension prevalence (p < .001).
  • The adjusted R-squared value of .684 indicates that the model explains approximately 68.4% of the variance in hypertension prevalence.

Source note: The poster’s narrative states that all variables have p < .001; its regression table reports p = 0.015 for Urban.

Discussion

Hypertension Prevalence Disparities

  • Significantly higher prevalence in food deserts compared to non-food desert areas.
  • Hypertension prevalence increased with communities of an increased percentage of 55 and older.
  • Increased socioeconomic advantage associated with reduced hypertension risk.

Consistency with Existing Literature:

  • Testa and colleagues (2021) found food deserts were linked to a heightened risk of hypertension.
  • Identified gaps in methodologies regarding food deserts and socioeconomic measures.
  • Extension Beyond Individual-Level Analyses:
    • This study utilizes a food desert measure that incorporates transportation and low income.
    • Provides a comprehensive understanding beyond individual-level analyses in prior studies.

Limitations

  • There was no control over how the data was collected and what quality control measures were taken, which can impact the accuracy and reliability of the findings.
  • The data may have inherent biases due to the original purpose of the data collection or the source of the data.
  • Due to the cross-sectional nature of the datasets, causality could not be established.

Policy Implications and Future Research

  • Policy:
    • Implement community garden or farmer’s markets in food deserts.
    • Enhance public transportation options.
  • Future Research:
    • Prospective cohort study design.
    • Consider additional features of food environments.
    • Include a measure to account for food delivery services.

Conclusion

This study conducted a thorough analysis of secondary data obtained from various sources to assess the association between hypertension prevalence and geospatial factors such as food deserts lacking transportation, walkability, park access, and urban/rural status in California at the census tract level. The study found significant differences in hypertension prevalence between food deserts lacking transportation and non-food desert census tracts, cumulative socioeconomic advantage, age, walkability, park access, and race/ethnicity. These findings suggest that access to healthy food options plays a vital role in preserving good health, particularly in the management of hypertension.

Acknowledgements

  • I would like to thank each of my committee members for their guidance and time.
  • Thank you, Dr. Garza, Dr. Rahman, Dr. Alcala, and Dr. Quinonez, for all the support you have provided during this process.

RESEARCH POSTER PRESENTATION DESIGN © 2011

www.PosterPresentations.com

http://www.facebook.com/pages/PosterPresentationscom/217914411419?v=app_4949752878&ref=ts

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.