Social Determinants of Health: The San Joaquin Valley
John A. Capitman, PhD
Emanuel Alcala, MA
Fresno State
Central Valley Health Policy Institute
Printed page 2
This Work was Supported By
- The California Endowment
- Fresno State — Central Valley Health Policy Institute
- CHAPS — Children’s Health & Air Pollution Study
- San Joaquin Valley Public Health Consortium — Health Equity for All
- UCSF Fresno
Printed page 3
Overview
Printed page 4
Background
- Place Matters Report of the San Joaquin Valley
- The premature death rate in the poorest zip codes is nearly double the rate in the most affluent.
- Premature mortality is highest in zip codes with higher % Latinos and higher poverty
- Similar findings for life expectancy. 21 years differences between zip codes.
Map description: The map shows variation in premature mortality across the San Joaquin Valley. County labels are San Joaquin, Stanislaus, Merced, Madera, Fresno, Kings, Tulare, and Kern. Shading ranges from pale yellow for the lowest premature mortality to dark red for the highest. Areas in the highest category appear in several counties, including San Joaquin, Fresno, Tulare, and Kern. Individual zip-code values are not labeled.
| YPLL per 1,000 | Legend description |
|---|---|
| 52 - 74 | Highest Premature Mortality |
| 46 - 51 | Intermediate category |
| 43 - 45 | Intermediate category |
| 39 - 42 | Intermediate category |
| 34 - 38 | Intermediate category |
| 18 - 33 | Lowest Premature Mortality |
(*YPLL: Years of Potential Life Lost)
Additional map legend entries: Zip Codes; County Boundary; National Parks/Forests; Roads; Water.
Map scale: 0, 15, 30, 60 Miles. North is indicated.
Data-source credit transcription: GeoLytics Estimates Premium Package - US Version; US Geologic Survey, NED Download Tool, 2010; California Death Masterfile, 1999-2007. Some of the small GeoLytics date and version details are not clearly legible in the supplied PDF.
Social Determinants of Health (SDOH)
- Place, Economic and Social History; Individual and Structural Racism, Classism
-
Arrows lead to both:
- Current & Cumulative Exposure to Living Conditions, Resource Access, and Civic Voice Inequities
- Access to Preventive Care; Health Behavior and Service Use
- Current & Cumulative Exposure to Living Conditions, Resource Access, and Civic Voice Inequities
-
Arrows lead to both:
- Health Inequities by Class, Race, Ethnicity, Gender, Age, and Residence
- Access to Preventive Care; Health Behavior and Service Use
- Access to Preventive Care; Health Behavior and Service Use
- An arrow leads upward into the pathway toward Health Inequities by Class, Race, Ethnicity, Gender, Age, and Residence.
- Health Inequities by Class, Race, Ethnicity, Gender, Age, and Residence
- An arrow leads to Grouped Differences in Hospitalization and Death.
The source uses multiple colored arrows between the first three main boxes but provides no legend defining those colors.
SDOH for Unique Populations
Fresno State — Central Valley Health Policy Institute
Determinants of Health: For each population, Place leads to Living Conditions, Living Conditions lead to Health Inequities, and Health Inequities lead to the population’s Health Outcome. Place and Living Conditions also each lead to Individual Behavior; Individual Behavior feeds into the pathway toward Health Inequities.
| Population | Determinants of Health | Health Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Children | Place; Living Conditions; Individual Behavior; Health Inequities | Preventable Hospital Use |
| Young Women | Place; Living Conditions; Individual Behavior; Health Inequities | Sexual Experiences and Birth Outcomes |
| Elders | Place; Living Conditions; Individual Behavior; Health Inequities | Chronic Disease and Longevity |
Printed page 7
Data and Approach
- Community-Level Data
- Census.gov
- CalEnviroScreen
- Regional Opportunity Index
- Walk Score®
- Individual-Level Data
- Birth Statistical Master Files
- Death Statistical Master Files
- Emergency Department Visits
- Hospital Discharge Data
- Approach is to apply statistical methods to identify individual and community characteristics that are strongly associated with specific health outcomes
Health Outcomes Throughout Life-Course
Printed page 8
Health Outcome: Preventable Hospitalizations in Children
- Hospitalization for Ambulatory Care-Sensitive Conditions (ACSC)
- These potentially preventable events were identified from the Agency for Healthcare
Research and Quality’s Prevention Quality Indicators which include:
- Acute respiratory infection
- Asthma
- Dehydration
- Criteria for analysis inclusion
- Primary diagnosis of an ACSC
- Ages 0 – 14
- Child resides in the San Joaquin Valley
- Hospitalized in 2012
- These potentially preventable events were identified from the Agency for Healthcare
Research and Quality’s Prevention Quality Indicators which include:
Printed page 9
Individual Characteristics: Preventable Hospitalizations in Children
In the following transcription of Table 1, each demographic cell gives N followed by the percentage in parentheses. Blank source cells are marked “Not reported.” Values and asterisks are retained as printed.
| Characteristic and Category | San Joaquin Valley: N (%) | ACSC Hospitalizations — Total: N (%) | ACSC Hospitalizations — White/Non-Hispanic: N (%) | ACSC Hospitalizations — Hispanic & Other: N (%) | ACSC Hospitalizations — African-American: N (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gender: Male | 47,400 (50%) | 3,646 (55**%) | 973 (54%) | 2,371 (55%) | 302 (57%) |
| Gender: Female | 47,200 (49%) | 2,906 (44**%) | 814 (45%) | 1,873 (44%) | 219 (42%) |
| Age Group in Years: <1 | 132,000 (13%) | 1,543 (23**%) | 372 (20%) | 1,075 (25%) | 96 (18%) |
| Age Group in Years: 1-4 | 202,000 (21%) | 2,706 (41**%) | 772 (43%) | 1,768 (41%) | 166 (31%) |
| Age Group in Years: 5-9 | 291,000 (30%) | 1,516 (23**%) | 413 (23%) | 944 (22%) | 159 (30%) |
| Age Group in Years: 10 - 14 | 321,000 (33%) | 787 (12**%) | 230 (12%) | 457 (10%) | 100 (19%) |
| Payer: Medi-Cal | 543,000 (57%) | 4,414 (67**%) | 842 (47%) | 3175 (74%) | 396 (76%) |
| Payer: Private Coverage | 332,000 (35%) | 1,726 (26**%) | 807 (45%) | 873 (20%) | 72 (13%) |
| Payer: Other Government | 63,000 (6%) | 351 (5%) | 117 (6%) | 190 (4%) | 44 (8%) |
| Payer: Self-Pay | 9,000 (<1%) | 61 (<1%) | 21 (1%) | 31 (<1%) | 9 (1%) |
| Race/Ethnicity: White/Non-Hispanic | 212,000 (22%) | 1787 (27**%) | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported |
| Race/Ethnicity: Hispanic & Other | 684,000 (72%) | 4244 (64**%) | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported |
| Race/Ethnicity: African-American | 51,000 (5%) | 521 (8**%) | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported |
| Measure | San Joaquin Valley | ACSC Hospitalizations — Total | ACSC Hospitalizations — White/Non-Hispanic | ACSC Hospitalizations — Hispanic & Other | ACSC Hospitalizations — African-American |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rate† | Not reported | 68 | 78 | 62 | 127 |
| Total | 980,053 | 6,552 | 1,787 | 4,244 | 521 |
1 Population estimates for the San Joaquin Valley derived from the California Health Interview Survey.
† Rate of preventable hospitalizations per 10,000.
* Z-test comparing population to ACSC hospitalizations, p < .01.
Transcription note: The source cells use double asterisks (**), while the source explanatory note uses a single asterisk (*).
Printed page 10
SDOH: Preventable Hospitalizations in Children
Symbol transcription: ↑ is an upward arrow; ↓ is a downward arrow; - is a dash; ↓/- combines a downward arrow and a dash. These symbols are retained from the source. The slides do not supply a written definition of the dash or the combined symbol. “Ref” identifies a reference category.
| Community-level Indicators | All Children | Under 1 | Medi-Cal | White | African American | Latino/Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pollution Burden Score | ↑ | ↑ | ↑ | ↑ | ↑ | ↑ |
| Low Poverty | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| Simpson Diversity Index | ↑ | ↑ | ↑ | - | ↑ | ↑ |
| Primary Care-Shortage Areas | ↑ | ↑ | ↑ | - | - | ↑ |
| Pollution Burden Score X Low Poverty | ↓/- | - | ↓/- | - | - | - |
Source: Lessard LN, Alcala E, & Capitman JA (2015). Journal of Pediatrics.
Printed page 11
Health Outcome: Premature Birth
- Premature Birth
- Premature birth < 37 gestational weeks
- Criteria for inclusion in analysis
- Mother aged 15 - 40 who reside in the San Joaquin Valley
- Birth between 2009 - 2013
Printed page 12
SDOH: Premature Birth
| Community-level Indicators | Sig. |
|---|---|
| Economic Opportunity | ↓ |
| Particulate Matter 2.5 | ↑ |
| Housing | - |
| Civic Life Opportunity | - |
| Education | - |
| Individual-level Indicators | Sig. |
|---|---|
| white | Ref |
| African American | ↑ |
| Latino | - |
| Asian/Pacific Islander | ↑ |
| Other Race/Ethnicity | ↑ |
| Private Insurance | Ref |
| Medi-Cal | ↑ |
| Other Insurance | ↑ |
| Individual-level Indicators | Sig. |
|---|---|
| Mother with 4-year Degree | ↓ |
| Smoke | ↑ |
| Hypertension | ↑ |
| WIC Services | ↓ |
| Previous Premature Birth | ↑ |
| Inter-pregnancy Period <33 M | ↑ |
Printed page 13
Health Outcome: Years of Life Lost in Mexican American Elders
- Years of Life Lost
- Life expectancy – age at death = years of life lost
- Life expectancy adjusted for gender and age group
- Criteria for inclusion in analysis
- Death occurred at age 65+
- Identified as Mexican American or white
- Resided in the San Joaquin Valley
- Life expectancy – age at death = years of life lost
Printed page 14
Individual Characteristics: Years of Life Lost in Mexican American Seniors
| Measure | Female — White | Female — Mexican American | Male — White | Male — Mexican American |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Life Expectancy at Age 65: Nationwidea | 20.3 | 22 | 17.6 | 19.4 |
| Life Expectancy at Age 65: California | 21.9 | 22.2 | 20.7 | 21.1 |
| Life Expectancy at Age 65: San Joaquin Valley | 20.9 | 21.8 | 18.6 | 20.6 |
| Mean (SD) Years: Age at Death | 83.3 (8.7) | 80.9* (8.4) | 80.4 (8.6) | 79.1* (8.4) |
| Mean (SD) Years: Years of life lostb | -0.21 (5.0) | 1.01* (5.0) | -0.15 (4.5) | 0.53* (4.6) |
* p < .01.
a Hispanic estimate by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2010
b negative values exceed life expectancy
Source: Alcala E & Capitman JA (2015). Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences. In Press.
Printed page 15
SDOH: Years of Life Lost in Mexican American Seniors
| Community-level Indicators | Sig. |
|---|---|
| Walk Score® | ↓ |
| Poverty | ↑ |
| Primary Care-Shortage Area | - |
| Percentage of Hispanics | - |
| Individual-level Indicators | Sig. |
|---|---|
| Married | ↓ |
| High School | Ref |
| No High School Diploma | ↓ |
| 4-year Degree or More | ↓ |
| US-Born White | Ref |
| US-Born Mexican | ↑ |
| Foreign-Born Mexican | ↑ |
| Cause of Death | Sig. |
|---|---|
| Circulatory | Ref |
| Neoplasm | ↑ |
| Respiratory | ↑ |
| Central Nervous System | ↓ |
| Endocrine | ↑ |
| Other Cause | ↑ |
Source: Alcala E & Capitman JA (2015). Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences. In Press.
Geographic Distribution of Indicators
Printed page 16
Geographic Distribution: Place Indicators
| Indicator | Poverty | Simpson Index | PM2.5 | Walk Score | % African American |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Poverty | 1 | ||||
| Simpson Index | -0.022 | 1 | |||
| PM2.5 | -0.012 | .263** | 1 | ||
| Walk Score | .321** | .387** | .343** | 1 | |
| % African American | .140* | .575** | 0.099 | .348** | 1 |
| % Latino | .721** | 0.021 | 0.126 | .334** | -0.062 |
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
Blank cells reproduce blank cells in the source matrix.
Printed page 17
Geographic Distribution: Health Outcomes
Map description: The map shows selected areas in Madera, Fresno, Kings, and Tulare counties. Different colors identify areas in the top quintile for ACSC Hospitalizations, Years of Life Lost, Premature Birth, or at least two indicators. Areas with overlapping indicators appear south of Fresno and in the southern Kings County area. Individual zip codes, numerical outcome values, and quintile thresholds are not labeled.
| Map color | Source legend label |
|---|---|
| Tan | No Indictors |
| Pale yellow | ACSC Hospitalizations |
| Light turquoise | Years of Life Lost |
| Pink-red | Premature Birth1 |
| Darker turquoise | At least two indicators present |
1 Premature birth at census tract level. Health outcomes are predicted mean values after controlling for individual- and community-level variables.
Printed page 18
Discussion
- An illustration of the Earth coughing amid pollution has a downward arrow pointing to a child.
- An illustration of a person carrying a large money bag has a downward arrow pointing to a woman holding an infant.
- An illustration of a tree and park bench has a downward arrow pointing to a group of older adults seated around a table.
Printed page 19
Implications for Strategy
- If specific SDOH affect specific health inequities, how does this influence community strategy to produce fair health outcomes?
- Options
- Narrowly-focused collective impact effort (e.g. PTBi)
- Broad focus on multiple aspects of living conditions (e.g. general plan changes and implementation advocacy)
- Broad focus collective impact collaborative (e.g. community health improvement plan)
- Is your Place Matters initiative adopting one of these strategies? Or others?
- How is your Place Matters initiative tracking and articulating policy approaches across different aspects of SDOH and different inequitable health outcomes?
Printed page 20